The next movie that has been compared to she’s the man, is shakespeare’s play, the twelfth night this play, which is much older than the first mentioned, weirdly enough, shares a lot of the same character names including viola, olivia, and orsino. Viola’s role in she’s the man could be described as pro-feminist, buy there are many underlying messages in the film and viola’s characterisation that highlight the differences between a female and a male, albeit the physical ones. Twelfth night vs she's the man essay twelfth night, she’s the man she’s the man is a loosely based modernized version of the famous shakespeare play, twelfth night they have the same basic plots girl is in disguise as her twin brother for her own reasons, which evolves into a distorted love triangle title, language and setting are a. She’s the man, a modern film that is based on the plot of shakespeare’s twelfth night the film's connections to the play are emphasized through a number of visual and dialogue references the film is about a young girl named viola who is a strong and tomboyish. “ twelfth night” and “ she’s the man ” have many differences so if your reading this it means you want to know the differences between “ twelfth night ” and “ she’s the man ” take the setting for example.
The paper notes that the 2006 film she's the man clearly pays homage to shakespeare's comedy twelfth night in the names of its main characters and the bare-bones outline of its cross-dressing plot, however, the paper points out many differences. Best answer: i believe that she's the man was based (loosely) on twelfth night they have the same basic plots: girl is masquerading as her twin brother for her own reasons girl has crush on a guy but can't tell him because it would break her cover. She’s the man is a modern film adaptation of william shakespeare’s twelfth night there are numerous differences amongst the two in the play sebastian and viola are twins and viola washes up on the shore of illyria. Wherein shakespeare's twelfth night is run through the same mill that turned the taming of the shrew into 10 things i hate about you (and with equally fun results.
Open document below is an essay on the twelfth night vs she's the man from anti essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples. A twelfth night character named malvolio is another man who loves olivia, and feste is the fool in olivia's court but she's the man combined these into the character malcolm feste, and gave. She's the man is better than twelfth night because of many reasons she's the man had a better adaptation because it was easier to understand the plot its plot was very interesting, and it was easier to understand than twelfth night's plot adding on, twelfth night's adaptation was good too, but it was hard to understand the plot because of. Athlete vs debutant she's the man takes after twelfth night but is focused on its teen audience therefore eliminating shakespeare's underlying issues cesario olivia’s steward in twelfth night feste the clown in twelfth night, is the last name of malcolm in she’s the man.
The plots of she’s the man and twelfth night run along similar lines, such as olivia kissing sebastian rather than the disguised viola, or duke enlisting “sebastian” (the disguised viola) to help him gain olivia’s attention (in the play, the duke orsino enlisted “cesario” to help him win olivia. She's the man is based on twelfth night the twins are named viola and sebastian the characters duke, olivia, andrew and toby also appear in both the play and the movie. The plots of she's the man and twelfth night run along similar lines, such as olivia kissing sebastian rather than the disguised viola, or duke enlisting sebastian (the disguised viola) to help him gain olivia's attention (in the play, the duke orsino enlisted cesario to help him win olivia. “she’s the man” is a modern retelling of shakespeare’s comedy, “twelfth night,” set – as they all seem to be, these days – at an expensive private school. Twelfth night, by william shakespeare, is a comedy that involves a shipwreck on the coast of the island of illyria after two siblings believe each other to be dead, viola, the sister of the two, decides to disguise herself as a man and work under the authority of duke orsino.
Compare “twelfth night” with she's the man while she's the man derives its love triangle and the names of its characters from twelfth night, it owes at least as much to the 1985 teen sex romp just one of the guys, which itself owed an unacknowledged debt to shakespeare's plot. She’s the man and twelfth night both end with the formation of relationships in the play everybody gets married and in the movie there is a debutante ball to which everybody has an escort as i read twelfth night, i struggled with thinking about and comparing it to she’s the man. Shes the man came out roughly 400 years after shakespeare wrote twelfth night while there are some similarities between the two works, there are far more differences the main similarities that are easily noticed are the names of the main characters being the same, and the basic plot staying the same. Twelfth night is one of shakespeare’s so-called transvestite comedies, in which a female character—in this case, viola—disguises herself as a man this situation creates a sexual mess: viola falls in love with orsino but cannot tell him, because he thinks she is a man, while olivia, the object of orsino’s affection, falls for viola in.
Viola - a young woman of aristocratic birth, and the play’s protagonistwashed up on the shore of illyria when her ship is wrecked in a storm, viola decides to make her own way in the world she disguises herself as a young man, calling herself cesario, and becomes a page to duke orsino. She's the man is a ridiculous but ultimately entertaining teen movie which takes the gender-bending action of shakespeare's twelfth night and drops it in the middle of a modern-day american boarding school. She's the man twelfth night the love triangle the genre of both shakespeare's twelfth night and she's the man are based on romance and comedy in both pretends to be male but for different purposes in twelfth night, viola does it to protect herself and also get love from orsino in. She's the man is a lovely and hilarious comedy filmed in the united states it was directed in 2002 by andy fickman and is based on the play the twelfth night written and composed by william shakespeare.